Star Wars: Rogue One, the Misogynist’s Nightmare

Way back in April, I wrote a post on Meerkat Musings that explored the misogyny that exploded into life when the first Rogue One trailer dropped. ‘Another female lead’, decried men who couldn’t handle this idea. Naturally, nothing else about the film mattered.

With the new trailer having debuted earlier today, this criticism of the film has returned. Let me explain why it’s completely unfounded, and instead rooted in some misguided ideas.

I’m quoting from a site called Mr Harmanson.

Welp, since one wasn’t enough, the Big D had to double down:

Coming to theaters soon is Episode 2 of Star Wars: Female Reboot.  Gear up this December for an Epic Showdown between Woman and Sinister Man who for some reason will get his ASS kicked despite having every MENTAL and PHYSICAL advantage.  Prepare yourself to JOURNEY across the stars with said Female while she rallies a group of MALES who would otherwise SHIT on their own FEET but with the Woman manage to save the GALAXY.

Soooo, the same thing we had last December?  Got it.

Whoa, there’s some serious anger here toward the idea of having leading female characters in Star Wars. His complaint in this paragraph is aimed at the character of Rey, who beat Kylo Ren in a duel at the end of The Force Awakens. Did Ren have every mental and physical advantage? Well, he was shaken by the fact that even as his father was dying in his arms, he showed his son he still loved him. He was hit by remorse and guilt and questioning his choices, so no, I don’t think he was mentally stronger than Rey at that point. He had also been shot, and by the time he fought Rey he’d already been exerting himself in an injured state against Finn.

Let’s not forget that Rey is apparently powerful in the Force, perhaps more so than Ren, and finally, Snoke mentions that Ren’s training is not complete.

So does it stretch the imagination a little to think that Rey could beat Ren? Maybe a little, but certainly not to the extent implied here, and I can’t imagine this article being written if Finn were in Rey’s place and had beaten Ren. It’s got everything to do with Rey being a woman.

What happened to you, America?  You used to be cool.

Listen, I’ve said this before, other people have said this before, and I will keep saying it: these type of movies do not work with a female lead.  Women are caretakers, nurturers, sympathizers, and nest-ers.  They are not battle leaders.  They are not warriors.  They are not adventure-seeking badasses.  Cripes, why is this hard to understand?  It’s not like we’ve had thousands of years of evolution for evidence.

Let’s see how many stereotypes we can fire off in one paragraph. Let’s also betray our ignorance of Star Wars (Princess Leia was in the thick of the fight in Return of the Jedi, and kicked ass in A New Hope as well. To say nothing of women who serve in the armed forces in real life). Evolution isn’t responsible for the roles Harmanson defines – social constructs are.

I suppose it’s because people’s memory on these things lasts about 3 days.  A week if we’re lucky.  In this time frame, woman have always been running the world.  Wait, why do men even exist?  I can’t remember.

Go ahead, everyone — send me all your anecdotal evidence of awesome broads.  Talking to you, feminists, and you, pussy men who are trying to suck up to women.  Whatever you send, I don’t care because I deal in bigger terms.

In other words, his mind is made up, he’s convinced himself he’s right and no facts will actually change his mind.

Let’s run it back one more time for the short bus: these movies are for little kids.  Little kids like to play make believe.  Little girls make believe about pretty houses, dolls, and playtime with their best friends.  Little boys pretend they’re off in space killing bad guys.  And in these little boys’ imaginations, who do you think is alongside them?

If Star Wars is for little kids (which isn’t true anyway, but that’s beside the point) then why is Harmanson so worked up about it? The gender stereotyping here betrays what he believes men and women should be doing, and it’s utterly offensive to both men and women to catagorise people in such a fashion.

This person? *

Or this person?

Or, for the young boys who will one day get shoved in lockers, it may also be this person:


One day the world will figure it out.


* OK, she may be in my fantasies, but you get what I mean.

So aside from objectifying Rey, he also fails to understand something about Star Wars – it has A: always had strong female characters and female characters in positions of authority, and B: In six of the eight films made so far, male characters have been in the lead positions. Furthermore, men are hardly marginalised in The Force Awakens – I guess the contributions of Han and Finn are overlooked by Harmanson.

8 thoughts on “Star Wars: Rogue One, the Misogynist’s Nightmare

  1. By this logic, I am a man. True, I’m no bada** fighting intergalactic – or even terrestrial – battles, but I’m deeeefinitely not a nest-er, not a nurturer, or caretaker (although, I think sympathy is a human emotion, which both genders can achieve; c’mon… if your buddy’s wife leaves him, you take him for a beer & talk about what a b**** she was & that’s sympathy!).

    My female friends & I would play firefighter as kids, &, yes, I carried one of ’em around the playground, much to the derision of my fellow students… but that’s because we were breaking societal norms. Girls don’t like playing house, playing with baby dolls, & putting on fake makeup. They’re taught this from a young age: from when their parents buy their first “Daddy’s Lil Princess” onesie while her brother gets “Future Player” on his onesie. To me, it’s kind of disingenuous to say that girls shouldn’t see strong female characters on screen because of something that isn’t innate; something that’s learned. Teach women to be bada**es, & they’ll be bada**es, imo.

    So, back to my first sentence… do I have to tell all my current partners or do you think I can skate on my physical self (&, y’know, the fact that I know I’m a woman)? This is just tearing me up inside! 😉


      1. No problem! I’m glad it looks like you’ve change someone’s mind about this, too. It would’ve been hard for me to write something like this without running off on a frustrated tangent, so I’m just glad you were able to do it coolly and effectively.

        Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.